Streetlaw

Bridging the gap between the law and the society

Recent Posts

Breaching the gap between the law and the society

Breaking

Taking the law to the streets

Wednesday, February 20, 2019

February 20, 2019


RE: SHOOT AT SIGHT FOR BALLOT BOX
SNATCHERS

(1). UNITED NATIONS BASIC PRINCIPLES ON THE USE OF FORCE AND FIREARMS BY LAW ENFORCEMENT OFFICIALS

Principle 2 – Governments and law enforcement agencies should develop a range of means as broad as possible and equip law enforcement officials with various types of weapons and ammunition that would allow for a differentiated use of force and firearms. These should include the development of non-lethal incapacitating weapons for use in appropriate situations, with a view to increasingly restraining the application of means capable of causing death or injury to persons. For the same purpose, it should also be possible for law enforcement officials to be equipped with self-defensive equipment such as shields, helmets, bullet-proof vests and bullet-proof means of transportation, in order to decrease the need to use weapons of any kind.

Principle 4 – Law enforcement officials, in carrying out their duty, shall, as far as possible, apply non-violent means before resorting to the use of force and firearms. They may use force and firearms only if other means remain ineffective or without any promise of achieving the intended result.

Principle 5 – Whenever the lawful use of force and firearms is unavoidable, law enforcement officials shall: (a) Exercise restraint in such use and act in proportion to the seriousness of the offence and the legitimate objective to be achieved; (b) Minimize damage and injury, and respect and preserve human life; (c) Ensure that assistance and medical aid are rendered to any injured or affected persons at the earliest possible moment; (d) Ensure that relatives or close friends of the injured or affected person are notified at the earliest possible moment.

Principle 7 – Governments shall ensure that arbitrary or abusive use of force and firearms by law enforcement officials is punished as a criminal offence under their law.

Principle 8 – Exceptional circumstances such as internal political instability or any other public emergency may not be invoked to justify any departure from these basic principles

Principle 9 – Law enforcement officials shall not use firearms against persons except in self-defence or defence of others against the imminent threat of death or serious injury, to prevent the perpetration of a particularly serious crime involving grave threat to life, to arrest a person presenting such a danger and resisting their authority, or to prevent his or her escape, and only when less extreme means are insufficient to achieve these objectives. In any event, intentional lethal use of firearms may only be made when strictly unavoidable in order to protect life.

Principle 10 – In the circumstances provided for under principle 9, law enforcement officials shall identify themselves as such and give a clear warning of their intent to use firearms, with sufficient time for the warning to be observed, unless to do so would unduly place the law enforcement officials at risk or would create a risk of death or serious harm to other persons, or would be clearly inappropriate or pointless in the circumstances of the incident.

Principle 24 – Governments and law enforcement agencies shall ensure that superior officers are held responsible if they know, or should have known, that law enforcement officials under their command are resorting, or have resorted, to the unlawful use of force and firearms, and they did not take all measures in their power to prevent, suppress or report such use.

Principle 25 – Governments and law enforcement agencies shall ensure that no criminal or disciplinary sanction is imposed on law enforcement officials who, in compliance with the Code of Conduct for Law Enforcement Officials and these basic principles, refuse to carry out an order to use force and firearms, or who report such use by other officials.

Principle 26 – Obedience to superior orders shall be no defence if law enforcement officials knew that an order to use force and firearms resulting in the death or serious injury of a person was manifestly unlawful and had a reasonable opportunity to refuse to follow it. In any case, responsibility also rests on the superiors who gave the unlawful orders.
From
Nonso Attoh

(2). Hon Justice Onu, J.S.C said in IBIKUNLE V. STATE  (2007) 2 NWLR (Pt.1019) 546,

“I am in agreement with the respondent that these statutory defences implied in these provisions set out above cannot avail the appellant, more so THAT NONE OF THEM GRANTED HIM A LICENSE TO SUMMARILY EXECUTE THE DECEASED EXTRA JUDICIALLY. Even if the deceased were to be a thief or a person of dubious character, which the evidence on record does not disclose him as one, the provisions of the Constitution and Criminal Procedure Law (ibid) quoted above DID NOT LICENSE THE APPELLANT TO BE THE COMPLAINANT, INVESTIGATOR, JUDGE AS WELL AS EXECUTIONER, ALL ROLLED INTO ONE… It is a misconception of the provisions of Section 7(1) and (2) of the Criminal Procedure Law (CPL) for the appellant to contend that the use of firearm was reasonable in the circumstances of this case. Even if the deceased were to be a thief or a person of dubious character, a fact not disclosed on the record, the provisions of the Constitution and the Criminal Procedure Law (ibid), did not license the appellant to be the complainant, investigator, as well as the Judge and executioner, all rolled into one… THE USE OF THE FIREARM WAS TOTALLY UNREASONABLE, HIGHLY INTIMIDATING AND UNCALLED FOR IN THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THIS CASE. This is because as found by the court below, the deceased did not pose any scintilla of danger to the appellant. It was mischievous and unreasonable for the appellant to break the window of the deceased’s apartment, threw teargas into the room and then jumped into the apartment to callously release or pump bullets into the deceased.
(capitalization supplied for emphasis)
From
NONSO ATTOH

(3). W. S. N. ONNOGHEN, J.S.C, stated in IBIKUNKE V. STATE (2007) 2 NWLR (pt 1019) 546

“The law does not permit or license any person, be he a policeman or soldier or otherwise to be the complainant, investigator, Judge and executioner all at the same time. In the circumstance of this case and particularly having regard to the provisions of section 33(2)(b) of the 1999 Constitution and section 7(1) and (2) of the Criminal Procedure … appellant has no legal right to summarily execute any person who refuses him ingress into an apartment that he believes a suspect is hiding…. I am compelled by the facts and circumstances of this case coupled with the now notorious extra judicial killings of innocent people by some members of the Nigeria Police to condemn the inability of some members of the police force to realize that the foundation of the police institution is preservation of life and property.”

From NONSO ATTOH

Source:

https://thenigerialawyer.com/limitations-to-the-right-to-life-and-the-use-of-force-against-violators-of-electoral-law-by-nonso-robert-attoh/

Tuesday, February 12, 2019

February 12, 2019

THE CONVENTION ON THE ELIMINATION OF ALL FORMS OF DISCRIMINATION AGAINST WOMEN (CEDAW)



Adopted by the United Nations General Assembly and came into force in 1981.
CEDAW is commonly referred to as the international bill of rights for women. It defines what constitutes discrimination against women and girls and sets out a comprehensive framework for tackling gender inequality.

THE ARTICLES
Article 1 - Definition of ‘discrimination against women’
Discrimination against women includes any distinction, exclusion or restriction made on the basis of sex that has the effect or purpose of impairing or nullifying women’s enjoyment of human rights and fundamental freedoms in the political, economic, social, cultural, civil or any other field. This is irrespective of their marital status, on a basis of equality of men and women.

Article 2 - Duty of States
States agree to pursue by all appropriate means a policy of eliminating discrimination against women, undertaking to take concrete steps to eliminate discriminatory laws, policies and practices in the national legal framework.

Article 3 - Equality
States shall take all appropriate measures to ensure the full development and advancement of women so as to guarantee them the enjoyment of human rights and fundamental freedoms on a basis of equality with men. This is in all fields but in particular the political, social, economic and cultural fields.

Article 4 - Special measures
States are allowed to adopt temporary special measures to accelerate de facto equality for women until the objectives of equality of opportunity and treatment have been achieved. States are allowed to adopt special measures aimed at protecting maternity.

Article 5 - Stereotyping and cultural prejudices
States shall take appropriate measures to eliminate stereotyping, prejudices and discriminatory cultural practices. States shall also ensure that family education includes a proper understanding of maternity as a social function and the recognition of the roles of men and women in the upbringing of their children.

Article 6 - Trafficking and prostitution
States shall take all measures to stop all forms of trafficking and the exploitation of prostitution of women.

Article 7 - Political and public life
States shall ensure that women have equal rights with men to vote, hold public office and participate in civil society.

Article 8 - Participation at the international level
States shall ensure that women are allowed to represent their governments at the international level and to participate in the work of international organisations.

Article 9 - Nationality
States shall grant women equal rights with men to acquire, change or retain their nationality and also equal rights in respect of their children’s nationality.

Article 10 - Education
States shall ensure that women have equal rights with men in education, including equal access to schools, vocational training, curricula and educational resources. States shall eliminate stereotypes of the roles of women and men through revising school materials and teaching methods.

Article 11 - Employment
States shall ensure that women the same opportunities as men in employment, promotion, training, equal remuneration, social security and safe working conditions. Women must also be protected in respect of pregnancy, maternity and marital status.

Article 12 - Health
States shall ensure that women have equal rights with men to access to health care services, including reproductive health services.

Article 13 - Economic and social benefits
States shall ensure that women have equal rights with men to family benefits, bank loans and other forms of financial credit. Women must also be allowed to participate equally in recreational activities, sports and all aspects of cultural life.

Article 14 - Rural women
States shall take all appropriate measures to eliminate discrimination against women in rural areas so that they can participate in and benefit from health care, education, social security, development planning etc equally with men.

Article 15 - Equality before the law
States shall ensure that women and men are treated equally before the law. Women have the same legal right to enter contracts, own property and choose their place of residence.

Article 16 - Marriage and family life
States shall ensure that women have equal rights with men in relation to marriage and as parents, as well as in respect of other aspects of family life.

Articles 17 - 24
These articles describe the composition and procedures of the CEDAW
Committee, the relationship between CEDAW and national and international
legislation and the obligation of States to take all steps necessary to implement CEDAW in full.

Articles 25 - 30 - Administration of CEDAW
These articles describe the general administrative procedures concerning
enforcement of CEDAW, ratification and entering reservations.

Saturday, February 9, 2019

February 09, 2019

By Farooq Kperogi.


The auguries already favor a decisive Atiku win in the forthcoming February 16 election, and the biggest electoral shock may actually come from the northwest, hitherto Buhari’s impregnable electoral fortress. The silent majority of voters in the region will ventilate their pent-up anger and frustration against Buhari in ways that will signal a tectonic disruption of the habitual voting patterns of the region. At this point, Buhari isn’t a threat to Atiku. INEC Chairman Professor Mahmood Yakubu is actually Atiku’s most potent threat now. Here is why.

A brother of the INEC chairman’s close friend confided in me today that the electoral boss has a deep-seated animus toward Atiku and has made many nasty, unkind remarks about Atiku in private. That, in and of itself, is not the problem. We are all entitled to our personal predispositions and biases as long as they don’t interfere with our judgement on occasions that invite our neutrality and fairmindedness.

However, the same source told me the INEC chairman has a profound personal investment in APC’s electoral successes, like Maurice Iwu had in PDP’s victories. He said the INEC chairman told his friend that he was going to hand victory to APC in the Osun governorship election even though PDP clearly and handily won it. Buhari’s unguardedly candid confession on January 27 at the banquet hall of the Osun State Government House that APC won the Osun governorship election with “remote control” is the biggest corroboration of this previously uncirculated whisper.

The go-to rhetorical strategy to impeach the credibility of uncomfortable, anonymous but veridical revelations like this is to call them “fake” and to dismiss them as ill motivated. Well, I’ve confirmed the INEC chairman’s ill will against and active personal hostility toward Atiku from other credible sources that should know. I’m so sure of my information that I can swear by Allah that Professor Yakubu isn’t neutral toward Atiku and has said unmentionably disparaging things about him in private. I invoke the wrath of Allah upon me if I am making this up. I hope Professor Yakubu, who is a Muslim like me and with whom I have personal familiarity, can do the same.

I concede that INEC has taken many admirable actions in the past few months that point to some degree of independence. It has also conducted a few elections in which APC lost, but that may just be window-dressing to conceal plans for the grand presidential electoral heist on February 16. The world needs to know that the INEC chairman isn’t neutral toward all the presidential candidates. There are many other disturbing things I’ve heard about the INEC chair that I’ll withhold for now because I haven’t independently confirmed them. It suffices to say, nonetheless, that the INEC chairman is NOT a neutral arbiter in the forthcoming election. Domestic and international observers—and Atiku’s agents—should observe him with heightened sensitivity. This is not Attahiru Jega; this is a less evil version of Maurice Iwu.

Sunday, January 27, 2019

January 27, 2019

United States of America, Department of State U.S. Embassy & Consulate in Nigeria Statement on the Suspension and Replacement of the Chief Justice



“The Embassy of the United States is deeply concerned by the impact of the executive branch’s decision to suspend and replace the Chief Justice and head of the judicial branch without the support of the legislative branch on the eve of national and state elections.

We note widespread Nigerian criticism that this decision is unconstitutional and that it undermines the independence of the judicial branch. That undercuts the stated determination of government, candidates, and political party leaders to ensure that the elections proceed in a way that is free, fair, transparent, and peaceful – leading to a credible result.

We urge that the issues raised by this decision be resolved swiftly and peacefully in accordance with due process, full respect for the rule of law, and the spirit of the Constitution of Nigeria. Such action is needed urgently now to ensure that this decision does not cast a pall over the electoral process.”


Saturday, January 26, 2019

January 26, 2019

Buhari suspends Onnoghen, swears in Mohammed as acting CJN




President Muhammadu Buhari has suspended the Chief Justice of the Federation (CJN), Justice Walter Onnoghen.

In his place, he has sworn in Justice Ibrahim Tanko Mohammed in an acting capacity.

He performed the ceremony at the presidential villa, Abuja on Friday.

President’s Special Assistant on New Media, Mr Bashir Ahmad.

In his place, Ahmad said through his twitter handle, @BashirAhmaad, that Justice Ibrahim Tanko Muhammed, was named by the President.



January 26, 2019

RESOLUTIONS OF THE NBA OWERRI BRANCH DURING HER MONTHLY GENERAL MEETING HELD ON THE 26/1/2019.



SUSPENSION OF THE HON. CHIEF JUSTICE OF NIGERIA:

 The Bar resolved the following in a motion moved and seconded by Chief C.C. Onyeagbakor and L.U.N. Nwakaeti, Esq respectively

1. That Owerri Bar rejects in its entirety the purported and unconstitutional suspension of the Hon. CJN by the President of FRN.
2. That Owerri Bar hereby empowers the chairman and executive members of the Bar to attend the NEC meeting of the NBA on Monday 28/01/2019 and insist on the branch position that all legal process must be followed to ensure that this Constitutional breach is reversed.
3. That in addition to (2) above, Owerri Bar resolved that NBA should take all other steps including but not limited to the total boycott of Courts and if the need arises the shutting down of the polity in collaboration with Civil Society Groups.
4. That the Attorney General of the Federation and the Vice President be called upon to resign for being complicit in the Constitutional breach.
5. That in addition to (4), the Attorney General of the Federation and the Vice President should face disciplinary committee of the Bar for disciplinary actions; and
6. That in line with the precedent laid in Abia State, that the NJC should dismiss the purported Acting CJN who presented himself to be sworn in, in circumstances that they are in pari material with Abia State case.
January 26, 2019

ONNOGHEN: LEGAL VOYAGE ON MANY QUESTIONS SORROUNDING THE TRIAL AND PURPORTED EXPARTE ORDER


THE IRREGULARITIES ON THE ORDER OF THE CCT MOTION EXPARTE
The face of the Order clearly shows that it was not moved by a counsel. In other words, the Application was moved suo motu by the court and on its volition. This is indeed strange.
DID THE PRESIDENT EVEN COMPLY WITH THE ALLEGED ORDER BY THE CCT?
The answer is in the negative. 
The President made heavy weather about complying with an Order from the CCT.
The President violated the alleged Order made by the CCT. A careful study of the enrolled Order shows that the Order only directed the CJN to STEP ASIDE as the Chief Justice of Nigeria and the Chairman of the National Judicial Council. Consequent upon the CJN stepping aside, then the second Order follows which is the order that the President swear in the most senior Justice of the Supreme Court.
But the President in paragraph 16, of his address stated thus “It is against this background that I have received the Order of the Code of Conduct Tribunal DIRECTING ME TO SUSPEND pending the final determination of the cases against him. It also explains why I am complying immediately… ”
Two things are glaring.
One, the President said he was directed to SUSPEND the CJN. The wordings of the alleged Order are clear and unambiguous. There is no such order directing the president to suspend the CJN!. 
Two, the President stated that the Order from the CCT directed him to suspend the CJN “pending the final determination OF THE CASES AGAINST HIM”.  A glance at the Order will again reveal that the President did not comply with the Order he alleged he was complying with.
The Order from the CCT asked that the most senior Justice be sworn in pending the determination the determination OF THE MOTION ON NOTICE.
There is a clear difference between an Order made pending the determination of Motion on Notice and an Order Pending the final determination of the cases against him. While the former abates when the Motion on Notice is taken and determined, the latter enures till the conclusion of the entire trial.
In any case, a Motion Exparte cannot be made “Pending the final determination of the case”.
The above inconsistencies clearly reveal the intent of the president and the desperation of the Government to REMOVE the CJN.
CAN THE PRESIDENT ADD OR VARY THE ALLEGED ORDER OF COURT?
The answer is in the negative.
The President while pretending to be complying with the Order of the CCT cannot add to, remove or vary the order. That is the law.
IS IT PROPER TO ORDER THE CJN TO STEP ASIDE VIA AN EXPARTE ORDER.?
This again is in the negative
Exparte Orders are sparingly made and in situation of extreme urgency, compelling enough as to leave the court with no other alternative in preventing an anticipated injury of a grave nature. See Group Danone & Anor v. Voltic (Nig.) Ltd. (2008) 3-4 S. C. 32 
One is tempted to ask, what is the irretrievable damage or urgency involved that cannot wait till Monday, 28, 2019 being the next adjourned to warrant the grant of the Order?
In view of the nature of the Order, is it not deserving that the respondent be put on Notice, rather than via Exparte Order that are made without hearing the other party?
IS THE TRIBUNAL CLOTHED WITH THE REQUISITE JURISDICTION TO MAKE THE ORDER?
The answer is in the negative.
This is owing to the fact that the jurisdiction of the tribunal has been contested. In the circumstance, the only jurisdiction it has is to first decide whether it has jurisdiction and nothing more!
Authorities are legion that jurisdiction is the very basis on which any court tries a case; it is the lifeline of all trials. It is trite that the issue of jurisdiction is a threshold and is paramount and of great importance in the adjudication of any matter. Jurisdiction of a court has to do with the competence of the court to entertain and determine a matter.
Interestingly, the CCT had adjourned to January 28, 2019 to consider the application challenging its jurisdiction.

It is the law that where a court has no jurisdiction to hear or determine a matter before it, any step taken in relation to the matter is a nullity and void.” See also the case of NCC v. MTN (Nig) Comm. Ltd. (2008) 7 NWLR (Part 1086) 229 at 260 paras. A-B.

MYSTERY ON DATES:
The Petition against the CJN by the Anti- Corruption and Research Based Data Initiative (ACRBDI) was received by the Code of Conduct Bureau on the Wednesday 9th of January, 2019. The Charge was drafted on Thursday 10th January, 2019 and the Application to commence trial was filed on Friday 11th January, 2019. And the matter fixed for arraignment on Monday, January 14, 2019
It leaves one to wonder why the speed to put the CJN on trial, and how all steps towards his arraignment was concluded within a space of 2 working days.
Quite shockingly, even the purported Motion Exparte was dated 9th of January, 2019, the day the petition was received, even before the Charge was drafted.
HAS THE CJN’S RIGHT TO FAIR HEARING NOT BEEN SERIALLY VIOLATED.
The twin pillars of natural justice which are –
(1) let the other side be heard and
(2) one cannot be a judge in his own cause which are summed up in the Latin maxim

It is the duty of the court to create the environment for fair hearing in an egalitarian   manner for the benefit of the parties. Most especially in a criminal charge.

IS IT PROPER FOR THE TRIBUNAL NOT TO OBEY ORDER OF COURTS?

The answer is in the negative.
There are 3 subsisting Orders against the CCT. Also, there is an Order of the Court of Appeal. All restraining the tribunal from proceeding with matter.
It is trite that matters appertaining to judicial orders or judgments, for that matter, are not generally treated with arrogance or levity.  It is rather officious and treading on a perilous path for one to arrogate to oneself the right to choose and pick between court orders in terms of whether they are valid or null and void. In fact, since there is a strong presumption in favour of the validity of a court's order, it behoves everyone to keep faith with the order of the court. It makes no difference that ex-facie it appears that the court that made the order is without jurisdiction because at the end of the day an order of the court subsists and must be obeyed until set aside by a court of competent jurisdiction.
To, therefore, disobey an order of the court on the fancied belief that the said order is null for any reason whatsoever - even if it subsequently turns out that the order in fact is proved to be null - is a risky and unadvisable decision because until the said order is finally determined to be null and void by the court. the order subsists with the string attaching to it unmitigated." See Babatunde v. Olatunji (2000) LPELR-SC.148/1995 Per ACHIKE J.S.C. (P.23, paras. A-F).

IS THE PRESIDENT CONSTITUTIONALLY EMPOWERED TO SUSPEND THE CJN WITH OR WITHOUT AN ORDER FROM THE CCT?
The Legislature is the custodian of a country's Constitution in the same way that the Executive is the custodian of the policy of Government and its execution, and also in the same way that the Judiciary is the custodian of the construction or interpretation of the Constitution.
This makes the 3 Arms separate. The Judiciary is not an appendage of the Executive.
There is no provision in our Constitution, the grund norm that authorises the President to suspend the CJN, in like manner, the CCT cannot make an order, asking the CJN to “step aside”, without any recourse to the Senate or the NJC.
It is also a principle of interpretation that the language of the Constitution where clear and unambiguous, must be given its plain evident meaning and that a Constitutional provision should not be construed so as to defeat its evident purpose. See Hon. Michael Dapianlong & Ors v. Chief (Dr.) Joshua Chibi Dariye & Anor (2007) 4 S. C.  (Pt. III) 18
It is good law that where the Constitution or a statute provides for a pre¬condition to the attainment of a particular situation, the pre-condition must be fulfilled or satisfied before the particular situation will be said to have been attained or reached. Our common and popular expression is "condition precedent" See Inakoju & Ors v. Adeleke & Ors. (2007) 4 NWLR (Part 1025) 423, Per Niki Tobi JSC (as he then was) (of blessed memory)
From the above, it goes even without saying that the purported suspension of the Chief Justice of Nigeria, Honorable Justice Walter Onnoghen by President Muhammadu Buhari is unconstitutional illegal, undemocratic, null and void and has no legal footing whatsoever.
SEPREBOFA M. OYEGHE ESQ

Thursday, January 24, 2019

January 24, 2019

NYESOM WIKE APPOINTED A LIFE BENCHER



The Executive Governor of Rivers State, His Excellency, Governor Ezenwo Nyesom Wike, was today, 24th January, 2019 appointed a Life Bencher by the Body of Benchers.
The ceremony took place at the Supreme Court Complex Abuja.

The Governor who was called to the Nigerian Bar in 1998, joins a list of distinguished lawyers who have been so appointed as Life Benchers.

Sunday, January 20, 2019

January 20, 2019

What then is professional ethics? - Okechukwu Orisakwe Esq

                     Okechukwu Orisakwe Esq

I’ve been reading some comments by highly revered Senior Advocates, trying to justify President Buhari’s absence and indict Atiku’s. These SANs have, with due respect, become notorious for unguarded comments that tend to turn the law upside down in some circumstances or heat up the polity at other times. While the CJN saga was fresh, I even heard one of them dishing out all manner of bad words to the Honourable Justices that decided the much hyped Ngajinwa’s case, saying, inter alia, that their Lordships reached an “illegal and unconstitutional decision”.
My colleagues can recall that in addition to the several provisions of the Rules of Professional Conduct for Legal Practitioners, Section 12 of the Legal Practitioners Act provides that a Lawyer should not be found guilty of “infamous conducts” or engage in acts “unbecoming of a Legal Practitioner”. I am mindful that a breach of any or all of these provisions could bring down the sledge hammer of the Legal Practitioners’ Disciplinary Commitee... Now I ask, do we agree that the calamitous and political statements of these Senior Advocates that heat up our polity constitute “infamous conducts” as well as conducts “unbecoming of a Legal Practitioner”? My humble answer is in the affirmative.
If our collective answers are in the affirmative (which I believe they should), has the LPDC become a toothless dog? Or rather, that kind of dog that can only intimidate other domestic animals but nothing more? What about the LPPC that conferred the tank of SAN upon them, is it not high time they stripped them off of that hallowed silk? I recall what happened to Michael Andoaaka, former AGF who was stripped off his silk for political comments that weren’t as heavy as what we hear from the people under reference in this post. What is sauce for the goose, they say, is sauce for the gander. The nobility and integrity of this profession is being daily ridiculed.
And if that doesn’t stop, I am afraid the profession will ultimately find obscurity as it’s terminus...

January 20, 2019

APC NATIONAL AND COCKTAIL OF ILLEGALITIES IN IMO STATE- _EX TURPI CAUSA NON ORITUR ACTIO!


                     Prof. Nnamdi Obiaraeri

It is a well known legal aphorism that you cannot put something on nothing and expect it to stand but APC National seems hell bent on doing the legally impossible in its Imo State Chapter.

The Adams Oshiomole led APC NWC has acquired the uncommon notoriety of being outlaws, compromised, incompetent, corrupt, inept and reckless party officials.

Sadly, this has led to heavy casualties in the electoral fortunes of the party with the dreary prospect that APC may not field candidates in the around the corner general elections in Zamfara, Rivers, Osun and even Enugu States.

The foundation of any democratic enterprise is obedience to rule of law and robust party politics revolves around obedience to party constitution but these ideals📌 sound strange or alien to the APC National Chairman.

Needless to say that the numb and impolitic leadership style of Adams Oshiomole has taken a great toll on the membership of the otherwise flourishing party in government .

Contrary to the express provisions of APC Constitution plus a valid and subsisting judgement (including order of perpetual injunction) of the Federal High Court Abuja recognising the Hon Chief Dan Nwafor led Imo APC Executive as the authentic officers of APC down to the Local Government and ward levels, the hard nosed Adams Oshiomole unilaterally purported to dissolve the elected Imo Exco and appointed a Chief Marcon Nlemigbo "Caretaker Committee".

In the eyes of the law, this dissolution of a democratically elected Imo APC Executive and the subsequent composition of an undemocratic "Caretaker Committee" is illegal, null, void and of no effect.

To add salt to injury, and as practical demonstration of the continuing drama of the absurd, the said Chief Marcon Nlemigbo led "Caretaker Committee" composed a Kangaroo "Disciplinary Committee" which allegedly tried in absentia some duly nominated APC National Assembly candidates in the next month's election and purportedly "suspended" these candidates from the party.

What a charade or huge joke taken too far.

📌Who gifts away six or seven national assembly positions out of thirteen (three Senate and ten House of Representatives) to the opposition before balĺots are cast except a man determined to shoot himself on the hip? 

Without fear of contradiction,  Chief Marcon Nlemigbo ought reasonably to know, at least as a lawyer (although a very new wig), that an illegal action can not give rise to a legal claim.

You can not give what you do not have- *nemo dat quod non habet.*

Chief Nlemigbo had no powers to convoke a "Disciplinary Committee" as he is merely a pretender to the office of State Chairman of APC and those egging him on are liable to be committed for contempt of court. 

Going by the judgement of the Federal High Court, the only valid and subsisting APC Executive in Imo State is that led by Hon Chief Dan Nwafor.

In view of the foregoing, the Caretaker Committee led by Chief Nlemigbo lacks the requisite *locus standi* to operate as officers of the party not to talk of setting up a "Disciplinary Committee" to try any person or duly nominated candidates of the party in a general election.

Even as this mockery or travesty of a recommendation of suspension is said to have been sent to APC NWC for consideration, the national officers need to be reminded that *"ex dolo malo non oritur actio",* meaning that a person who grounds his cause of action on an immoral or an illegal act can never be assisted.

Put succinctly, the Chief Nlemigbo led "Caretaker Committee" is unknown to law and his so called "Disciplinary Committee" is a hogwash, pooh pooh and tommyrot.

Inexorably, his "Disciplinary Commitee" remains a Kangaroo Committee whose mandate or terms of reference arose *ex turpi causa*📌 or in transgression of a judgement of a Court of Superior Records and positive laws of this country.

If not for purposes of irritation and political jaywalking, that Kangaroo "Disciplinary Committee" ought to know that their assignment was dead on arrival and their purported recommendation of the suspension of duly nominated national assembly candidates is illegal and ultra vires.

It is a complete waste of time and a monumental exercise in futility because going by irrevocable INEC timelines for the 2019 general election, the window for substitution of candidates by political parties has closed and the names of all national assembly candidates eligible to contest the general election published.

So how do you put something on nothing and expect it to stand?

Certainly, illegality cannot beget legality.

At this stage, only the death of a candidate can remove him or her from the ballot and certainly not the perverse findings of a Kangaroo Disciplinary Committee set up by an otherwise illegal Caretaker Committee.

Nigerians were expecting that after the Adams Oshiomole led NWC auctioned mandates and arbitrarily doled out undemocratic📌 automatic tickets in Imo APC, that the party will deploy strong post-primaries ADR techniques to calm frayed nerves of its members to no avail.

The APC National should immediately retrace its odious missteps and reverse the barage of calculated and premeditated undemocratic onslaughts on Imo APC.

Needless to say that the cocktail of ilegalities already recorded suggest clearly that the APC National does not wish the party well in Imo State but there is still a fighting chance because 24 Hours is a long time in politics. 

A word is usually not enough for the unwise.


A new normal is possible!


*Prof Obiaraeri is my name, the ☆☆☆☆☆ 5-Star Civilian General etc.*